Compare Auto Insurance Companies (2026)
Compare 2026 national sample premium benchmarks from Insurance.com for Travelers, State Farm, Geico, Progressive, Allstate, USAA, and Farmers.
We do not publish unsupported state-by-state prices by insurer. For a state average benchmark, see our 2026 state rate table; actual company pricing varies by ZIP code, vehicle and underwriting.
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Each page compares the cited national sample premiums and summarizes company features. Neither page predicts your state-specific price.
Travelers vs. State Farm
Travelers cheaper by ~27% nationally
Travelers vs. Geico
Travelers cheaper by ~2% nationally
Travelers vs. Progressive
Travelers cheaper by ~21% nationally
Travelers vs. Allstate
Travelers cheaper by ~34% nationally
Travelers vs. USAA
USAA cheaper by ~25% nationally
Travelers vs. Farmers
Travelers cheaper by ~32% nationally
State Farm vs. Geico
Geico cheaper by ~25% nationally
State Farm vs. Progressive
Progressive cheaper by ~7% nationally
State Farm vs. Allstate
State Farm cheaper by ~10% nationally
State Farm vs. USAA
USAA cheaper by ~45% nationally
State Farm vs. Farmers
State Farm cheaper by ~7% nationally
Geico vs. Progressive
Geico cheaper by ~20% nationally
Geico vs. Allstate
Geico cheaper by ~33% nationally
Geico vs. USAA
USAA cheaper by ~27% nationally
Geico vs. Farmers
Geico cheaper by ~30% nationally
Progressive vs. Allstate
Progressive cheaper by ~17% nationally
Progressive vs. USAA
USAA cheaper by ~41% nationally
Progressive vs. Farmers
Progressive cheaper by ~13% nationally
Allstate vs. USAA
USAA cheaper by ~51% nationally
Allstate vs. Farmers
Farmers cheaper by ~4% nationally
USAA vs. Farmers
USAA cheaper by ~49% nationally
National Average Rates at a Glance
| Insurer | Avg. Annual Rate | Best For | Availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| USAA | $1,572/yr | Active military, veterans, and their immediate family members. | Military/Veterans only |
| Travelers | $2,103/yr | Drivers prioritizing the cited 2026 overall survey rating. | All drivers |
| Geico | $2,148/yr | Drivers with good credit and clean records who prefer online service. | All drivers |
| Progressive | $2,675/yr | Drivers with prior accidents or tickets who want usage-based savings. | All drivers |
| State Farm | $2,874/yr | Drivers who want in-person service and bundling discounts. | All drivers |
| Farmers | $3,085/yr | Drivers who want highly customizable policies and local agent access. | All drivers |
| Allstate | $3,205/yr | Drivers who want comprehensive coverage and local agent support. | All drivers |
2026 modeled premiums; full coverage as defined in the source methodology. Source and methodology.
How to Compare Auto Insurance Companies
- Start with a benchmark — use the national sample averages above as a starting point; your local quotes can differ.
- Check your driver profile — rates vary by age, credit score, driving history and vehicle. The national averages do not determine which carrier is cheapest for your profile.
- Get at least 3 real quotes — rate tables show averages. Your actual quote depends on your ZIP code, vehicle, and underwriting.
- Compare coverage, not just price — look at deductibles, liability limits, and add-ons like rental reimbursement and roadside assistance.