Skip to main content
Auto Insurance Reviews 2025–2026

Auto Insurance Company Reviews (2025–2026)

We reviewed 37 auto insurers on price, claims satisfaction, customer service, coverage options, and digital experience. Ratings are based on J.D. Power studies, NAIC complaint data, AM Best financial strength, and publicly available rate filings.

What to compare in an insurer profile

Review available coverages and discounts in each company profile, then check state availability, policy exclusions, and current complaint or claims information with the insurer and your state insurance department. Ratings and sample rates are editorial reference points, not a guarantee of service or your price.

Insurers Reviewed

37

Avg. Annual Rate

$2,503

Lowest Rate

$1,890

Top Rated

USAA (4.8/5)

Top-Rated Insurers (4.0+ / 5)

USAA4.8/5Low Complaints

Best overall — but only for military members and their families.

$1,890/yr

avg rate

900/1000

J.D. Power

0.51

complaint idx

Review →
Amica Mutual4.6/5Low Complaints

Highest customer satisfaction in the industry — mutual company model.

$2,210/yr

avg rate

906/1000

J.D. Power

0.38

complaint idx

Review →
Erie Insurance4.5/5Low Complaints

Best regional insurer — top claims satisfaction and low complaint index.

$2,080/yr

avg rate

895/1000

J.D. Power

0.44

complaint idx

Review →
Geico4.4/5

Best rates for good-credit drivers — fully digital, no local agents.

$2,190/yr

avg rate

874/1000

J.D. Power

0.74

complaint idx

Review →
Auto-Owners Insurance4.4/5Low Complaints

Top-rated regional insurer with exceptional claims service.

$2,140/yr

avg rate

890/1000

J.D. Power

0.48

complaint idx

Review →
State Farm4.3/5

America's largest auto insurer — best for bundling and agent access.

$2,420/yr

avg rate

882/1000

J.D. Power

0.62

complaint idx

Review →
Acuity Insurance4.3/5Low Complaints

Top-rated regional insurer in the Midwest — exceptional service.

$2,160/yr

avg rate

N/A

J.D. Power

0.42

complaint idx

Review →
Progressive4.2/5

Best for high-risk drivers and rate comparison transparency.

$2,310/yr

avg rate

861/1000

J.D. Power

0.88

complaint idx

Review →
The Hartford4.2/5

Best auto insurer for drivers 50+ through AARP partnership.

$2,340/yr

avg rate

871/1000

J.D. Power

0.68

complaint idx

Review →
Cincinnati Insurance4.2/5Low Complaints

Strong regional insurer with excellent financial strength.

$2,240/yr

avg rate

N/A

J.D. Power

0.58

complaint idx

Review →
Travelers4.1/5

Strong for homeowners bundling auto — competitive rates in the Northeast.

$2,350/yr

avg rate

854/1000

J.D. Power

0.79

complaint idx

Review →
Shelter Insurance4.1/5

Strong regional insurer in the South-Central US.

$2,180/yr

avg rate

862/1000

J.D. Power

0.67

complaint idx

Review →
Nationwide4/5

Solid mid-tier insurer with strong vanishing deductible feature.

$2,480/yr

avg rate

859/1000

J.D. Power

0.92

complaint idx

Review →
American Family Insurance4/5

Strong Midwest insurer with excellent customer satisfaction.

$2,290/yr

avg rate

868/1000

J.D. Power

0.71

complaint idx

Review →
Westfield Insurance4/5

Solid regional insurer in the Midwest and Mid-Atlantic.

$2,200/yr

avg rate

N/A

J.D. Power

0.72

complaint idx

Review →
Hanover Insurance4/5

Strong independent agent insurer with broad coverage options.

$2,310/yr

avg rate

N/A

J.D. Power

0.76

complaint idx

Review →

All Other Insurers

Allstate3.9/5

Wide agent network with strong add-on coverage options.

$2,780/yr avg

Review →
AAA Insurance3.9/5

Best for AAA members — roadside assistance bundled in.

$2,410/yr avg

Review →
Donegal Insurance3.9/5

Regional insurer with strong Mid-Atlantic presence.

$2,170/yr avg

Review →
Farmers Insurance3.8/5

Broad coverage options with a strong agent network.

$2,690/yr avg

Review →
Safeco Insurance3.8/5

Liberty Mutual subsidiary with independent agent distribution.

$2,560/yr avg

Review →
MetLife Auto3.8/5

Employer-sponsored auto insurance with group discount benefits.

$2,380/yr avg

Review →
Liberty Mutual3.7/5

Flexible coverage with RightTrack telematics savings.

$2,920/yr avg

Review →
Mercury Insurance3.7/5

Competitive rates in California and select Western states.

$2,380/yr avg

Review →
Clearcover3.7/5

Lean digital insurer with low overhead and competitive rates.

$2,050/yr avg

Review →
Encompass Insurance3.7/5

Allstate subsidiary for independent agents — bundling specialist.

$2,640/yr avg

Review →
Esurance3.6/5

Allstate's digital-first brand for online shoppers.

$2,490/yr avg

Review →
Lemonade Insurance3.6/5

AI-powered insurer with instant claims and giveback program.

$2,190/yr avg

Review →
Foremost Insurance3.6/5

Specialty insurer for non-standard vehicles and high-risk drivers.

$3,120/yr avg

Review →
Root Insurance3.5/5

Telematics-first insurer — rates based primarily on how you drive.

$2,280/yr avg

Review →
National General Insurance3.5/5

Allstate subsidiary serving standard and non-standard drivers.

$2,870/yr avg

Review →
21st Century Insurance3.5/5

California-focused direct insurer with competitive rates.

$2,290/yr avg

Review →
Kemper Insurance3.4/5

Specialty insurer for non-standard and high-risk drivers.

$3,480/yr avg

Review →
Infinity Insurance3.4/5

Non-standard insurer specializing in California and the Southeast.

$3,380/yr avg

Review →
Dairyland Insurance3.3/5

Non-standard insurer for high-risk drivers and SR-22 filers.

$3,290/yr avg

Review →
Bristol West Insurance3.3/5

Non-standard insurer for high-risk drivers in select states.

$3,560/yr avg

Review →
GAINSCO Auto Insurance3.2/5

Minimum coverage specialist for high-risk drivers in the South.

$2,890/yr avg

Review →
Methodology: Overall ratings are a weighted composite of price (30%), claims satisfaction (25%), customer service (20%), coverage options (15%), and digital experience (10%). Average rates are for a 35-year-old driver with a clean record, good credit, and full coverage. J.D. Power scores are from the most recent Auto Insurance Study. Complaint indexes are from the NAIC; 1.0 = industry average, lower is better.

Compare Insurers Head-to-Head

See detailed side-by-side comparisons with sample rates by driver profile, score breakdowns, and FAQ.